Stop/Go Boards or Portable Traffic Signals? Choosing the Right Shuttle Working Method

When roadworks reduce a two-way road to a single open lane, traffic from each direction has to take turns. This is known as shuttle working, and it's one of the most common traffic management arrangements on UK roads.
There are two main active ways to control it: stop/go boards operated by trained operatives, or portable traffic signals. Both do the same basic job. The right choice depends on the site, and getting it wrong affects safety, cost and how well the road keeps moving.
How stop/go boards work
Stop/go boards are held by trained operatives positioned at each end of the works. They communicate with each other, usually by radio, and release traffic from one direction at a time.
The main advantage is human judgement. An operative can see the traffic in front of them, hold back a queue for an emergency vehicle, pause for a pedestrian or adjust to a delivery lorry blocking the lane. That flexibility makes boards well suited to:
Shorter-duration works
Sites where conditions change quickly, such as plant moving in and out
Locations where accesses, driveways or side roads make predictable timings difficult
The trade-off is that operatives must be in position for the full duration of the works, which affects cost on longer schemes. They also cannot be used in darkness unless the boards are directly illuminated.
How portable traffic signals work
Portable traffic signals control traffic automatically, using vehicle detection to respond to demand. They're well suited to:
Longer-duration works, including those left in place overnight
Junctions, where more than two approaches need controlling
Sites where operatives can't safely stand in position for long periods
Signals need careful set-up. Clearance times must allow the last vehicle to get through the works before opposing traffic is released, so they have to reflect the length of the site, gradients and approach speeds. Sight lines and detection need checking too. Signals on the public highway need the agreement of the local highway authority which needs building into your programme.
What decides the right method?
There's no default answer. When we assess a scheme, we look at:
The length of the works and the visibility from each end
Traffic volumes and peak times
Approach speeds
Junctions, accesses and bus routes within or near the works
Pedestrian and cyclist movements
How long the works will be in place, and whether they run overnight
Sometimes the answer changes during a scheme. Boards may suit the busiest phase of works, with signals taking over once activity settles.
Why individual assessment matters
A templated approach to shuttle working can mean long queues, frustrated drivers and, at worst, unsafe conflicts within the works. That's why every scheme Beaumont Traffic Management designs is individually assessed using nearly 30 years of experience on local networks.
Planning works that need shuttle working? Get in touch with our team to talk through the options for your site






Comments